ESCHATOLOGY AFTER VATICAN 2
1. The first thing to notice is that since Vatican 2, the eschatological perspective has been more clearly articulated as an essential aspect of ecclesial spirituality. This is in contrast to the time when ‘The Last Things’ was a comparatively neglected tract at the end of dogmatic theology – left to last in more senses than one! Moreover, in Scripture studies, though there had been a certain ‘rediscovery’ of eschatology among mainly Protestant exegetes, it soon became an area of endless divisions and subdivisions, eg., Consequent, Supratemporal, Existential, Realised, Anticipated, Proleptic, Prophetic, Political, etc., etc. But chapter 7 of Lumen Gentium, ‘The Pilgrim Church’ is an indication of how eschatology, far from being a special dogmatic tract, or a complicated area of exegesis, is a radical dimension of the life of faith.
2. Moreover, as is evidenced in Gaudium et Spes, the hope that finds expression in Christian eschatology is related to the larger experience of human hope. It is usual in most theological treatments of eschatology to begin such reflections with an analysis of the human experience of hope. The most impressive secular expression of this is the now classic multi-volume work of Ernst Bloch, The Principle of Hope (German original: Das Prinzip Hoffnung). Hope, and the imagination it gives rise to, is a creative force in history, making us look beyond the constrictions of any particular time and place and culture, to something inexpressibly more.
3. On a more psychological note, the positive experience of hope can be contrasted with its opposite, despair. For example, this negative attitude induces feelings of isolation: those who have lost hope cannot imagine that there is any help for them. Hope begins to be reborn when a sense of community is restored. Similarly, a sense of totalisation is characteristic of despair; the hopeless are overwhelmed by what they see as total failure. Once more the path of hope lies in the recovery of a sense of proportion. Another mark of despair is unreality. The hopelessness is caused by an expectation of perfection in others and in oneself that leaves no room for growth or change. Hope, therefore, begins again with a certain tolerance, patience and even sense of humour. Another symptom of despair is apathy. The hopeless not only give up on doing anything about the situation, but to even lack the desire to do anything. Hope begins to be restored when the hopeless person starts to desire a way out, and begins to do something to bring it about (see William F. Lynch, Images of Hope. Imagination as Healer of the Hopeless (University of Notre Dame Press, 1965).
4. Obviously that type of analysis leads very easily into essential aspects of Christian hope with its emphasis on community in Christ, the forgiveness of sins, the power of prayer, and hope for a new creation and eternal life. In line with Rom 5:1-5, the pressure of suffering produces the steadfast endurance typical of Job and martyrs of the OT, resulting in character in those who had been put to the test. The outcome is a realistic hope relying exclusively on God’s love experienced in our hearts through the gift of the Spirit. In many ways, this Pauline emphasis found in expression in ‘Liberation Theology’ as the acting-out of hope in situations of economic or political oppression.
5. Christian existence is impossible without such hope. Christian life can’t be reduced to ‘watching a replay of highlights’ – once our team has won. We are in the world, not as spectators but as participators in a great historical and cosmic drama. Here Romans 8:18-28 is a key text: the whole of creation groans in the pangs of childbirth, we groan within it awaiting our full liberation – and most mysteriously, the Spirit intercedes for us with groans too deep for utterance: these three ‘groanings’ – cosmic, personal, and divine – are irreplaceable aspects of the ‘groaning’ hope of Christian living.
6. Though the creeds are expressions of faith, they are also expressions of hope. Though the theme of ‘the love of God’ is not explicitly mentioned in any creed, the expression of faith/ hope would be inane if the whole background were not the most fundamental of all ‘articles of faith’– ‘God is love’ (1 John 4:8, 16). Hope is reliance on this love, surrender to it, and collaboration with it.
7. Typically, whatever form the official creeds take– or any expression of faith, for that matter– seven key terms (allowing for a variety of expressions) must be employed if the full scope and extent of God’s love is to be confessed: Father, Son, Cross, Resurrection, Spirit, Church, Kingdom/ Eternal life. In any account of Christian hope, no one of these terms can be omitted without mutilating the message. On the other hand, no more need be added, since all further doctrines reduce to these. Needless to say, these themes can be differently ordered depending on the emphasis we wish place on this or that aspect of the Gospel of salvation.
8. Here follows a brief statement on each of these seven terms in relation to the eschaton, ‘the last thing’, namely the reality of God as love:
In this is love, not that we loved God, but that he loved us and sent his Son into the world so that we might live through him (1 John 4:10).
God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life (John 3:16).
Jesus Christ... he is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not for ours only,
but also for the sins of the whole world (1 John 2:2).
the word of life– this life was revealed and we have seen it and testify to it, and declare to you the eternal life that was with the Father and was revealed to us– we declare to you what we have seen and heard... (1 John 1: 1-2).
And by this we know that he abides in us, by the Spirit he has given us (1 John 3:24).
We declare to you what we have seen and heard so that you may have fellowship [koinonia] with us; and our fellowship is with the Father and with his Son Jesus Christ (1 John 1:3).
Love has been perfected among us in this: that we may have boldness on the day of judgment, because as he is, so are we in this world. There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts our fear; for fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not reached perfection in love (1 John 4:17-18).
9. The listing of these seven key terms suggests how contemporary theology is seeking to integrate the eschatological horizon into every theme it treats. The logos, ‘the meaning’ of both Theos, ‘God’, and of the eschaton, ‘the last’ are necessarily interconnected.
10. Note, too, that the Gospel of hope promises a victory which appeals to human freedom and does not suppress it. God continues to have time for our whole history. The immediate radiant evidence of the Risen Lord, and the vision of the invisible God must wait to the end. Only in the energy of the Spirit, inspiring the faith and hope and love which abide (1 Cor 13:13) is love's victory communicated, as it transforms human lives, individually and communally, into anticipations of what is to be. The excess of evil calls forth the excesses of the `never ending' Love that `bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things' (1 Cor 13:7-8).
11. The manner in which God has entered human history to draw it into his own future is a communication to free beings. We are still living a history of freedom. And that distinctively human mode of existence needs time, takes time, to unfold to its full proportions. Though God is present in the incarnate and personal manner we have described, such a presence creates a ‘ free space’ around it to make room for our full human history. This is the space of the Spirit– inspiring our searchings and our hopes, stimulating desire and longing, impelling toward dialogue, and all the witness of different vocations and different gifts.
12. And yet, even though the last word on our future is addressed to the inconclusive and fragmented reality of human history, it does not lose its definitive character. For, as a whole, it has been claimed and possessed by God. As a whole, the human race has a divine future. Though theology has no right to utter judgments about the particular fate of individuals, it is within its capacity and responsibility to speak of an assured future for a whole humanity.
13. Hence, all the particular issues of eschatology are expressed, not as the disconnected themes of an abstract or inconclusive hope, but as extrapolations made from the burning centre of what is already occurring within our history. For where we are and how we are has already been penetrated by the divine. Through Christ, the reality of our world is already claimed and owned by God. The death and resurrection of the Lord has occurred as a mutation within the sphere of human existence.
14. Yet however varied the accounts of hope might be, there are constants in any authentic Christian hope. These reduce to two: first of all, the grace, the given-ness of the mystery of Christ; and secondly, the questing, ever-unfinished tending of our lives toward an ultimate wholeness and a final homecoming.
15. What then are the last things that eschatology fundamentally deals with? The traditional answer was clear: death, judgment, heaven, hell. The answer, far more fundamental, can be indicated under the following headings:
i/ God's Original Love:
The ultimate purpose of the universe, its essential character derives from the eschaton of the love of God. This comes to its victory in the glory of a universe transformed by the grace of God's self-giving in Christ. As St. Paul expresses it:
He destined us in love to be his sons [and daughters] through Jesus Christ according to the purpose of his will, to the praise of his glorious grace which he freely bestowed on us in the Beloved. (Eph 1:5-6)
This original and universal will of God, the mystery of creative and redemptive love, finds its consummation at the point of ultimate communication when `God may be everything to everyone' (I Cor 15:28). In this context, the eschatological prayer is, `Thy Kingdom come!'
ii/ Christ, the Ultimate Form:
As the ultimate form of the transformed universe and redeemed humanity, Christ himself is the eschaton. Again the words of Paul express this kind of finality:
He is the image of the invisible God, the first-born of all creation; for in him all things were created, in heaven and on earth... all things were created in him and for him. He is before all things, and in him all things hold together' (Col 1:15-17).
In such a context, the eschatological prayer is oldest Christian prayer recorded in New Testament, `Maranatha, Our Lord, come!' (1 Cor 16:22).
iii/ Spirit: the Ultimate Life:
As the energy impelling everything and everyone to achieve its ultimate form in Christ, and uniting all in him, the eschaton is the Spirit:
If the Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, he who raised Jesus from the dead will give life to your mortal bodies also through his Spirit who dwells in you (Rom 8:11).
Here, the prayer of hope is to join with the `sighs to deep for words' of the Spirit praying in all the hopeful prayers of the Christian (Rom 8:26). This finds expression in the invocation, `Come, Holy Spirit...'.
iv/ Transformed Humanity:
The last thing in terms of our human history is the resurrection of our humanity in a transformed universe. Neither the world nor our humanity is sacrificed in God's gracious design. The groaning of all creation in its cosmic activity of giving birth, the groaning of those who hope for our full redemption (Rom 8:22-23) envisages, not the destruction of our humanity or our world, but a creation rejoicing in the `glorious liberty of the children of God'. Here, the eschatological prayer is `Abba', `Our Father...'
Anthony J. Kelly, CSsR
University Professor of Theology,
Australian Catholic University
A.Kelly@acu.edu.au